UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
January 13, 2010
TDY HOLDINGS, ET AL., PLAINTIFFS,
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ET AL., DEFENDANTS.
The opinion of the court was delivered by: Hon. William V. Gallo U.S. Magistrate Judge
ORDER DENYING PLAINTIFFS' APPLICATION FOR REQUIRED APPEARANCE AT SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE
The Court is in receipt of the letter dated January 6, 2010, sent by Plaintiffs TDY Holdings, LLC and TDY Industries, Inc. (hereafter "TDY"), in which TDY requests that the Court order Defendant United States of America, et al., (hereafter "USA") to have a "senior Justice Department official" personally attend the Settlement Conference scheduled for February 19, 2010. The Court is also in receipt of the USA's responsive letter, dated January 11, 2010. For reasons set forth below, the Court DENIES the request.
The Court is aware of the history of the litigation in this case as well as the issues presented in TDY's and the USA's letters. While it is true that Magistrate Judge Louisa S. Porter, previously assigned to this case, ordered the USA "to have present an individual, other than defense counsel, who is familiar with the facts and circumstances of this case, the history of the site in question, its use, and remediation efforts -- historically, presently, and remediation plans for the future," it is not accurate nor correct to represent that Magistrate Judge Porter intended a senior Justice Department official to be that person. As explained in the letter from then-United States Attorney Alan D. Bersin to then-Presiding Magistrate Judge Roger C. McKee, dated July 18, 1996, (attached to the USA's letter), the requirement to compel the appearance of a senior Department of Justice official is onerous, burdensome, mostly impractical, and not supported by Congressional pronouncements. Although Mr. Bersin's letter is nearly 14 years old, his position continues to be the policy practiced in this judicial district.
There is no evidence to suggest that the USA is not negotiating in good faith. Representations otherwise are unnecessary, counter-productive, and without basis in fact.
Accordingly, it is ORDERED that TDY's request for a senior Department of Justice official to attend the Settlement Conference is DENIED.
It is FURTHER ORDERED, consistent with Magistrate Judge Porter's Orders of October 8 and 21, 2009, that counsel for the USA shall be accompanied at the Settlement Conference by an individual with intimate knowledge of the site in question. This person need not be a senior Justice Department official.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
© 1992-2010 VersusLaw Inc.