The opinion of the court was delivered by: Hon. Mitchell D. Dembin U.S. Magistrate Judge
ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO HAVE THE O'BRIEN DEPOSITION CONDUCTED AT THE U. S. COURTHOUSE [DOC. NO. 96]
Before the Court is Defendants' motion, filed on October 13, 2011, to have the deposition of one of its employees, Jayne O'Brien, taken at the U. S. Courthouse. (Doc. No. 96). Plaintiff filed a response in opposition the same day. (Doc. No. 97). Having considered the motion, the response and the docket of proceedings in the case, the Defendants' motion is GRANTED.
The parties have agreed that Plaintiff can take the deposition of Jayne O'Brien, an employee of Defendant who supervised Plaintiff, on November 8, 2011, beginning at 9:00 a.m. Defendants assert that the deposition should be taken at the U. S. Courthouse, a secure location, due to its concerns regarding Plaintiff's behavior. Defendants claim that Plaintiff has acted erratically and in a threatening manner at various times throughout this litigation. (Doc. No. 96). Plaintiff, in a 16-page response in opposition which primarily addresses other discovery orders under review before the District Court and Plaintiff's complaints regarding Defendants' discovery practices, claims that Defendants are merely seeking to deceive and to discredit Plaintiff. (Doc. No. 97).
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(c)(1)(B) provides that for good cause a court may issue an order specifying terms, including time and place, for discovery. This Court, in a discovery order under review, has determined that Plaintiff must submit to an Independent Medical Examination regarding her claimed severe and ongoing emotional distress. (Doc. No. 62). On October 7, 2011, the District Judge issued an order prohibiting Plaintiff from contacting chambers telephonically. (Doc. No. 92). Having the deposition occur in the courthouse does not discredit Plaintiff in any way; all it does is provide some comfort to the deponent and counsel that matters cannot escalate out of hand. This Court finds good cause to allow for the deposition to occur in a secure setting within the U. S. Courthouse.
Accordingly, Defendants' motion to have the deposition of Jayne O'Brien occur in the U. S. Courthouse is GRANTED. The deposition shall take place on November 8, 2011, beginning at 9:00 am, in the Jury Room associated with Courtroom D on the first floor of the U. S. Courthouse at 940 Front Street, San Diego, California. This Order also will serve as permission for the court reporter retained by Plaintiff for the deposition to bring audio and/or video equipment into the Courthouse for the deposition.
© 1992-2011 VersusLaw ...