Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Disney Enterprises, Inc., Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc., Dc Comics v. Sophia Shih A/K/A Sophia Shi

September 24, 2012

DISNEY ENTERPRISES, INC., WARNER BROS. ENTERTAINMENT INC., DC COMICS AND SANRIO, INC., PLAINTIFFS,
v.
SOPHIA SHIH A/K/A SOPHIA SHI, AN INDIVIDUAL AND D/B/A AUTO MATES AND AUTO MATES AND MORE AND DOES 1 -- 10, INCLUSIVE, DEFENDANTS.



The opinion of the court was delivered by: Hon. Audrey B. Collins United States District Chief Judge

J. Andrew Coombs (SBN 123881) andy@coombspc.com Annie S. Wang (SBN 243027) annie@coombspc.com J. Andrew Coombs, A Prof. Corp. 517 East Wilson Ave., Suite 202 Glendale, California 91206 Telephone: (818) 500-3200 Facsimile: (818) 500-3201 Attorneys for Plaintiffs and Counter-Defendants Disney Enterprises, Inc., Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc., DC Comics and Sanrio, Inc. and Third-Party Defendant Brand Security Corporation Dann L. Duncan (SBN 153259) loodld@yahoo.com Law Office of Dann L. Duncan 136 North Grand Avenue #318 P.O. Box 4308 West Covina, California 91791 Telephone: (626) 339-4976 Facsimile: (626) 339-4976 Attorney for Defendant and Counter-Claimant Sophia Shih a/k/a Sophia Shi, an individual and d/b/a Auto Mates and Auto Mates and More

ALL RELATED CLAIMS

[PROPOSED] CONSENT DECREE AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION

The Court, having read and considered the Joint Stipulation for Entry of Consent Decree and Permanent Injunction that has been executed by Disney Enterprises, Inc. ("DEI"), Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc. ("Warner Bros."), DC Comics and Sanrio, Inc. ("Sanrio") (collectively "Plaintiffs"), Brand Security Corporation ("BSC") and Defendant Sophia Shih a/k/a Sophia Shi, an individual and d/b/a Auto Mates and Auto Mates and More ("Defendant"), in this action, and good cause appearing therefore, hereby: ORDERS that based on the Parties' stipulation and only as to Defendant, her successors, heirs, and assignees, this Injunction shall be and is hereby entered in the within action as follows:

1) This Court has jurisdiction over the parties to this action and over the subject matter hereof pursuant to 17 U.S.C. § 101 et seq., and 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338.

2) DEI owns or controls the copyright, trademark and/or pertinent exclusive right to distribute or license the distribution of products incorporating its animated or live action characters or other logos subject to the copyright registrations listed in Exhibit "A" and/or the trademark registrations listed in Exhibit "B" attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference (the "DEI Properties").

3) Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc. owns or controls the copyright, trademark and/or pertinent exclusive right to distribute or license the distribution of products incorporating its animated or live action characters or other logos subject to the copyright registrations listed in Exhibit "C" and/or the trademark registrations listed in Exhibit "D" attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference (the "Warner Bros. Properties").

4) DC Comics owns or controls the copyright, trademark and/or pertinent exclusive right to distribute or license the distribution of products incorporating its animated or live action characters or other logos subject to the copyright registrations listed in Exhibit "E" and/or the trademark registrations listed in Exhibit "F" attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference (the "DC Comics Properties").

5) Sanrio owns or controls the copyright, trademark and/or pertinent exclusive right to distribute or license the distribution of products incorporating its animated or live action characters or other logos subject to the copyright registrations listed in Exhibit "G" and/or the trademark registrations listed in Exhibit "H" attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference (the "Sanrio Properties"). The DEI Properties, Warner Bros. Properties, DC Comics Properties, and Sanrio Properties are collectively referred to as Plaintiffs' Properties.

6) Plaintiffs have alleged that Defendant has made unauthorized uses of Plaintiffs' Properties or substantially similar likenesses or colorable imitations thereof.

7) Defendant and her agents, servants, employees and all persons in active concert and participation with her who receive actual notice of the injunction are hereby restrained and enjoined from -- directly, contributorily or vicariously -- or enabling, facilitating, permitting, assisting, soliciting, encouraging, inducing, authorizing, aiding or abetting, or materially contributing to in any manner, from:

a) Infringing Plaintiffs' copyrights and trademarks in Plaintiffs' Properties, either directly or contributorily, in any manner, including generally, but not limited to manufacturing, importing, distributing, advertising, selling, offering for sale, any unauthorized product which features any of Plaintiffs' Properties ("Unauthorized Products"), and, specifically:

i) Importing, manufacturing, distributing, advertising, selling, offering for sale, the Unauthorized Products or any other unauthorized products which picture, reproduce, copy or use the likenesses of or bear a substantial similarity to any of Plaintiffs' Properties; ii) Importing, manufacturing, distributing, advertising, selling, offering for sale, in connection thereto any unauthorized promotional materials, labels, packaging or containers which picture, reproduce, copy or use the likenesses of or bear a confusing similarity to any of Plaintiffs' Properties;

iii) Engaging in any conduct that tends falsely to represent that, or is likely to confuse, mislead or deceive purchasers, Defendant's customers and/or members of the public to believe, the actions of Defendant, the products sold by Defendant, or Defendant herself is connected with Plaintiffs, is sponsored, approved or licensed by Plaintiffs, or is affiliated with Plaintiffs; or

iv) Affixing, applying, annexing or using in connection with the importation, manufacture, distribution, advertising, selling, offering for sale, or other use of any goods or services, a false description or representation, including words or other symbols, tending to falsely describe or represent such goods as being those of Plaintiffs'.

8) Each side shall bear its own fees and costs of suit.

9) Except as provided herein, all claims alleged in the Complaint as to Defendant are dismissed with prejudice.

10) The claims for relief, and each of them, alleged by Defendant against Plaintiffs, BSC, Shannon Enox and Michael Chapman, in the "Counterclaim" filed on or about July 30, 2012, as Docket No. 27, shall be dismissed with prejudice, in its entirety.

11) Defendant confirms the seizure that took place on July 2, 2012, and Plaintiffs are given leave to destroy or otherwise dispose of the goods seized.

12) The Bond re Defendant (No. 105777926) in the amount of Five Thousand Dollars ($5,000.00) filed by Plaintiffs in connection with the temporary restraining order and order for seizure and impoundment is exonerated and discharged, and the surety on said undertaking shall have no further liability in connection therewith whatsoever.

13) This Injunction shall be deemed to have been served upon Defendant at the time of its execution by the Court.

14) The Court finds there is no just reason for delay in entering this Injunction and, pursuant to Rule 54(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the Court directs immediate entry of this Injunction against Defendant.

15) The Court shall retain jurisdiction of this action to entertain such further proceedings and to enter such further orders as may be necessary or appropriate to implement and enforce the provisions of this Injunction.

16) The above-captioned action, shall, upon filing by Plaintiffs of the Settlement Agreement, Stipulation for Entry of Judgment and Judgment Pursuant to Stipulation, and requesting entry of judgment against Defendant, be reopened should either Parties default under the terms of the Settlement Agreement.

17) This Court shall retain jurisdiction over Defendant for the purpose of making further orders necessary or proper for the construction or modification of this consent decree and judgment; the enforcement hereof; the punishment of any violations hereof; and for the possible entry of a further Judgment Pursuant to Stipulation in this action.

PRESENTED BY:

EXHIBIT A

DEI'S COPYRIGHTED DESIGNS

Copyright Registration Title of Work (Character) Type of Work

VA 58 937 Mickey - 1 (Mickey Mouse) Model Sheet VA 58 938 Minnie - 1 (Minnie Mouse) Model Sheet Gp 80 184 Donald Duck Publications

Model Sheet VA 58 933 Daisy -1 (Daisy Duck) Model Sheet VA 58 936 Goofy -1 (Goofy) Model Sheet Gp 80 192 Pluto Publications

Model Sheet VAu 64 814 Baby Mickey Model Sheet VAu 64 814 Baby Minnie Model Sheet VAu 73 216 Baby Donald Duck Model Sheet VAu 73 217 Baby Daisy Duck Model Sheet VAu 83 225 Baby Goofy Model Sheet VAu 73 219 Baby Pluto Model Sheet

R 48 971 Disney's Uncle Scrooge in Only a Poor

Old Man Comic Strip RE 424 728 Walt Disney's Ludwig von Drake Comic Strip Gp 105 126 Horace Horsecollar Model Sheet R 567 615 Chip Model Sheet R 567 614 Dale Model Sheet VA 184 345 Huey, Dewey & Louie -1 Model Sheet Gp 105 128 Clarabelle Cow Model Sheet RE 636 587 Winnie the Pooh and the Honey Tree Motion Picture RE 718 378 Winnie the Pooh and the Blustery

Day Motion Picture VA 58 940 Pooh - 1 (Winnie the Pooh) Model Sheet Gp 81 528 Rabbit Publications

Model Sheet Gp 81 528 Owl Publications

Model Sheet Gp 85 651 Kanga and Roo Publications

Model Sheet Gp 81 528 Eeyore Publications

Model Sheet Gp 81 528 Piglet Publications

Model Sheet Gp 81 528 Gopher Publications

Model Sheet Gp 81 527 Tigger Publications

Model Sheet R 354 235 Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Motion Picture R 346 870 Bashful Drawings R 346 869 Doc Drawings R 346 875 Dopey Drawings

R 346 876 Grumpy Drawings R 346 871 Happy Drawings R 346 874 Sleepy Drawings R 346 873 Sneezy Drawings R 346 872 Snow White Drawings R 346 868 Snow White "Witch" Drawings R 406 910 Pinocchio Motion Picture Gp 80 186 Pinocchio Publications

Model Sheet Gp 80 188 Jiminy Cricket Publications

Model Sheet R 427 860 Fantasia Motion Picture R 433 627 The Reluctant Dragon Motion Picture R 442 538 Dumbo Motion Picture R 428 428 Dumbo Suggestions for Dumbo Drawing R 428 420 Mother Elephant Suggestions for "Dumbo" Drawing R 428 430 Dumbo Ringmaster Suggestions 1348 Drawing R 428 427 Dumbo - Stork Suggestions Drawing R 428 426 Timothy Mouse Suggestions Drawing R 428 432 Dumbo "Miscellaneous Crows" - 2006 Drawing R 458 260 Bambi Motion Picture R 433 645 Bambi - Bambi Drawing R 433 630 Bambi - Final Thumper Model - 2002 Drawing R 433 631 Bambi - Skunk Model - 2002 Drawing R 433 636 Bambi - Owl and Stag Models Drawing R 433 632 Faline "Adolescent Age" Drawing R 433 633 Bambi's Mother Drawing R 467 541 Saludos Amigos Motion Picture R 464 785 Joe Carioca Drawing R 516 560 The Three Caballeros Motion Picture R 550 316 Make Mine Music Motion Picture R 557 922 Song of the South Motion Picture R 548 629 Brer Rabbit Drawing R 548 626 Brer Bear Drawing R 577 489 Fun and Fancy Free Motion Picture R 605 180 Melody Time Motion Picture R 636 303 The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr.

Toad Motion Picture R 648 396 Cinderella Motion Picture R 632 319 Cinderella Copyright Booklet R 632 319 Drizella Copyright Booklet R 632 319 Anastasia Copyright Booklet R 632 319 Stepmother Copyright Booklet R 632 319 Fairy Godmother Copyright Booklet R 632 319 Prince Copyright Booklet R 632 319 Bruno, the Dog Copyright Booklet R 632 319 Lucifer, the Cat Copyright Booklet R 632 319 Jaq and Gus Copyright Booklet RE 27 746 Alice in Wonderland Motion Picture

VA 58 920 Alice - 1 (Alice) Model Sheet VA 58 919 Alice - 2 (The White Rabbit) Model Sheet VA 58 921 Alice -- 3 (Queen of Hearts) Model Sheet VA 58 922 Alice - 4 (Cheshire Cat) Model Sheet VA 58 923 Alice - 5 (Caterpillar) Model Sheet VA 58 924 Alice - 6 (Tweedledee and Tweedledum) Model Sheet

VA 58 922 March Hare Model Sheet VA 58 922 Mad Hatter Model Sheet RE 64 027 Peter Pan Motion Picture RE 66 285 Peter Pan Coloring Book RE 66 285 Tinkerbell Coloring Book RE 66 285 Captain Hook Coloring Book RE 66 285 Mr. Smee Coloring Book RE 66 285 Nana Coloring Book RE 162 852 Lady and the Tramp Motion Picture RE 101 764 Lady Previews of

Pictures

RE 101 764 Tramp Previews of

Pictures

RE 296 296 Sleeping Beauty Motion Picture RE 246 671 Princess Aurora Book RE 246 671 Prince Phillip Book RE 246 671 Maleficent/Dragon Book RE 370 901 One Hundred and One Dalmatians Motion Picture RE 546 478 The Sword in the Stone Motion Picture RE 557 357 Archimedes Copyright Booklet RE 557 357 Merlin Copyright Booklet RE 557 357 Wart/Arthur Copyright Booklet RE 557 357 Madame Mim Copyright Booklet RE 571 201 Mary Poppins Motion Picture RE 705 510 The Jungle Book Motion Picture RE 679 798 Mowgli Drawing RE 679 799 Baloo Drawing RE 679 795 Bagheera Drawing RE 679 805 King Louie Drawing RE 679 797 Kaa Drawing RE 679 807 Shere Khan Drawing Lp 38 283 The Aristocats Motion Picture Gu 44 754 O'Malley Drawing Gu 44 750 Duchess Drawing Gu 44 748 Edgar Drawing Gu 44 745 Roquefort Drawing VA 1-099-033 Marie Valentine Spring 2002 Style Guide

Lp 39 817 Bedknobs and Broomsticks Motion Picture Gu 46 904 Crocky Drawing Gu 46 908 Sailor Bear Drawing Gu 46 906 Codfish Drawing Gu 46 917 Secretary Bird Drawing LP 42 905 Robin Hood Motion Picture Gu 46 582 Robin Hood Drawing Gu 46 583 Little John Drawing Gu 46 584 Sir Hiss Drawing Gu 47 230 Sheriff of Nottingham Drawing Gu 47 762 Friar Tuck Drawing Gu 46 585 Prince John Drawing Gu 50 764 Maid Marion Drawing Gu 50 763 Lady Cluck Drawing Lp 49 678 The Rescuers Motion Picture Gp 96 289 Miss Bianca Drawing Gp 96 286 Orville Drawing Gp 96 288 Madame Medusa Drawing Gp 96 287 Bernard Drawing Gp 103 814 Penny Drawing Gu 57 278 Rufus Drawing Gu 56 625 Evinrude Drawing PA 1 371 Pete's Dragon Motion Picture Gp 111 695 Elliott the Dragon Drawing PA 125 861 The Fox and the Hound Motion Picture VAu 10 933 Todd (Young) Drawing VAu 10 930 Copper (Pup) Drawing VAu 10 936 Vixey Drawing VAu 10 928 Big Mama Drawing VAu 12 417 Dinky Drawing VAu 12 418 Boomer Drawing VAu 12 415 Squeeks Drawing PA 252 525 The Black Cauldron Motion Picture VAu 24 517 Eilonwy Drawing VAu 29 561 Fflewddur Drawing VAu 24 518 Gurgi Drawing VAu 24 070 Hen Wen Drawing VAu 24 592 The Horned King Drawing VAu 24 519 Taran Drawing VAu 47 075 Orddu Drawing VAu 47 073 Orgoch Drawing VAu 47 074 Orwen Drawing PA 290 808 The Great Mouse Detective Motion Picture VAu 76 103 Basil 185-126 Model Sheet VAu 76 102 Dr. Dawson 1284-80 Model Sheet VAu 81 570 Olivia Model Sheet VAu 76 100 Ratigan 285-166 Model Sheet VAu 81 572 Fidget Model Sheet VAu 81 571 Flaversham Model Sheet VAu 86 112 Felicia - Clean Up Model 0238 Model Sheet VAu 76 104 Toby 285-170 Model Sheet VAu 85 019 Mrs. Judson Model Sheet VAu 85 021 Queen Victoria Model Sheet VAu 85 022 Bartholomew Model Sheet PA 385 556 Oliver and Company Motion Picture

VAu 104 921 Dodger Construction Sheets Model Sheet VAu 104 920 Einstein Construction Sheets Model Sheet VAu 104 919 Frances Construction Sheets Model Sheet VAu 104 916 Rita Construction Sheets Model Sheet VAu 109 377 Oliver Rough Model Model Sheet VAu 109 379 Tito - Ruff Model Model Sheet VAu 119 949 How to Draw Georgette Model Sheet PA 431 543 The Little Mermaid Motion Picture VAu 123 355 Ariel 9-9-87 Ruff (Ariel) Drawings VAu 123 351 Scuttle Drawings VAu 123 354 Ruff Sebastion 9-4-87 (Sebastian) Drawings VAu 123 348 Ruff Ursula 9-9-87 (Ursula) Drawings VAu 123 352 Prince Eric Drawings VAu 123 350 Triton Drawings VAu 123 353 Flotsam/Jetsam Drawings VAu 123 349 Flounder Drawings PAu 1 024 341 DuckTales Motion Picture VAu 101 067 Launchpad McQuack Pamphlet of Drawings VAu 101 067 Webby Pamphlet of Drawings VAu 101 067 Doofus Pamphlet of Drawings VAu 101 067 Mrs. Beakley Pamphlet of Drawings VAu 101 067 Duckworth Pamphlet of Drawings PA 486 535 The Rescuers Down Under Motion Picture VAu 161 749 Cody Model Sheets VAu 155 884 Jake (Rough Models) Model Sheets VAu 155 844 McLeach (Rough Model) Model Sheets VAu 170 264 Marahute (Rough Model) Model Sheets PA 542 647 Beauty and the Beast Motion Picture VAu 200 866 Belle (Beauty and the Beast) Artwork VAu 210 914 Beast Licensing Kit VAu 194 311 Maurice (Beauty and the Beast) Artwork VAu 199 855 Mrs. Potts (Beauty and the Beast) Artwork VAu 200 868 Cogsworth (Beauty and the Beast) Artwork VAu 194 310 Lumiere (Beauty and the Beast) Artwork VAu 201 337 Chip (Beauty and the Beast) Artwork VAu 194 307 Gaston (Beauty and the Beast) Artwork VAu 194 309 LeFou (Beauty and the Beast) Artwork VAu 199 856 Phillipe (Beauty and the Beast) Artwork VAu 200 869 Featherduster (Beauty and the Beast) Artwork PA 583 905 Aladdin Motion Picture VAu 215 432 Aladdin - Aladdin Model Sheet VAu 215 453 Aladdin - Genie Model Sheet VAu 215 793 Aladdin - Abu Model Sheet VAu 218 349 Aladdin - Iago Model Sheet VAu 230 534 Aladdin - Rasoul Model Sheet VAu 218 348 Aladdin - The Sultan Model Sheet VAu 230 533 Aladdin - Jafar Model Sheet VAu 221 841 Aladdin - Jasmine Model Sheet VAu 221 842 Aladdin - Jafar as Beggar Model Sheet VAu 232 164 Aladdin - Narrator Model Sheet PA 659 979 The Lion King Motion Picture VAu 246 448 The Lion King - Mufasa Model Sheet VAu 245 946 The Lion King - Sarabi Model Sheet VAu 246 447 The Lion King - Simba Model Sheet VAu 246 440 The Lion King - Young Simba Model Sheet VAu 246 438 The Lion King - Nala Model Sheet VAu 246 664 The Lion King - Young Nala Model Sheet VAu 245 947 The Lion King - Rafiki Model Sheet VAu 245 945 The Lion King - Shenzi, Banzai & Ed Model Sheet VAu 246 437 The Lion King - Pumbaa Model Sheet VAu 245 662 The Lion King - Timon Model Sheet VAu 246 446 The Lion King -Scar Model Sheet VA 611 201 Zazu Licensing Kit PA 720 179 Pocahontas Motion Picture VAu 262 859 Pocahontas - Pocahontas Standing Artwork VAu 261 970 Pocahontas - Powhatan Artwork VAu 261 967 Pocahontas - Percy Artwork VAu 302 884 Pocahontas - John Smith Artwork VAu 302 886 Pocahontas - Meeko the Raccoon Artwork VAu 302 883 Pocahontas - Flit the Hummingbird Artwork VAu 300 559 Pocahontas - Ratcliffe Artwork VAu 302 885 Pocahontas - Grandmother Willow Artwork PA 765 713 Toy Story Motion Picture VAu 337 565 Toy Story - Woody Artwork VAu 337 566 Toy Story -Buzz Lightyear Artwork VAu 337 567 Toy Story - Hamm Artwork VAu 337 568 Toy Story - Rex Artwork VAu 337 569 Toy Story -Bo Peep Lamp and Sheep Artwork VAu 337 186 Toy Story -Lenny Artwork VAu 273 627 Toy Story -Mom Artwork VAu 348 598 Toy Story -Andy Artwork VAu 348 599 Toy Story - Hannah Artwork PA 795 221 The Hunchback of Notre Dame Motion Picture VAu 336 992 The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Quasimodo Model Sheet VAu 332 434 The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Esmeralda Model Sheet VAu 336 056 The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Phoebus Model Sheet VAu 336 057 The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Djali Model Sheet VAu 343 663 The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Gargoyles Model Sheets VAu 336 058 The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Clopin Model Sheet VAu 336 059 The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Model Sheet Frollo VAu 336 878 The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Will

Doll/Sam Doll Model Sheet PA 670 961 Hercules Motion Picture VAu 369 603 Hercules - Hercules Model Sheets VAu 369 600 Hercules - Baby Hercules Model Sheets VAu 367 973 Hercules - Meg Model Sheets VAu 369 605 Hercules - Pegasus Model Sheets VAu 369 598 Hercules - Baby Pegasus Model Sheets VAu 367 965 Hercules - Phil Model Sheets VAu 367 964 Hercules - Hades Model Sheets VAu 367 969 Hercules - Pain Model Sheets VAu 375 850 Hercules - Panic Model Sheets VAu 377 944 Hercules - Hydra Head Model Sheet PA 799 025 Mulan Motion Picture VA 849 510 Mulan Style Guide VAu 379 045 The Legend of Mulan - Mulan Model Sheets VAu 379 027 The Legend of Mulan - Mulan as Ping Model Sheets VAu 379 021 The Legend of Mulan - Mushu Model Sheets VAu 379 024 The Legend of Mulan - Shang Model Sheets VAu 378 480 The Legend of Mulan - Kahn Model Sheets VAu 381 069 The Legend of Mulan - Cricket Model Sheets PA 901 890 A Bug's Life* Motion Picture VA 875 986 A Bug's Life* Style Guide VAu 399 357 Flik* Model Sheets VAu 399 356 Hopper* Model Sheets VAu 399 351 Atta* Model Sheets VAu 399 349 Dot* Model Sheets VAu 399 343 Dim* Model Sheets VAu 399 352 Tuck & Roll* Model Sheets VAu 399 350 Francis* Model Sheets VAu 399 348 Heimlich* Model Sheets VAu 399 353 Slim* Model Sheets VAu 399 342 Rosie* Model Sheets VAu 399 346 P.T. Flea* Model Sheets VAu 399 345 Manny* Model Sheets VAu 399 344 Gypsy* Model Sheets VAu 399 347 Thumper* Model Sheets VAu 399 354 Molt* Model Sheets VAu 399 355 Queen* Model Sheets PA 959 870 Toy Story 2* Motion Picture VAu 414 563 Toy Story 2 - Al's Car* Model Sheet VAu 405 573 Toy Story 2 - Bullseye* Model Sheet VAu 406 700 Toy Story 2 - Coffee Table* Model Sheet VAu 407 195 Toy Story 2 - Cushy Chair* Model Sheet VAu 405 571 Toy Story 2 - Emporer Zurg* Model Sheet VAu 405 572 Toy Story 2 - Jessie* Model Sheet VAu 405 197 Toy Story 2 - L'il Yuppie* Model Sheet VAu 405 574 Toy Story 2 - Prospector* Model Sheet VAu 407 196 Toy Story 2 - Wood Chair* Model Sheet VA960 902 Toy Story 2 - Style Guide* Style Guide PA 974 011 Dinosaur Motion Picture VAu 486 473 Aladar Model Sheet VAu 486 477 Baylene Model Sheet VAu 486 476 Bruton Model Sheet VAu 486 478 Eema Model Sheet VAu 486 475 Kron Model Sheet VAu 486 474 Neera Model Sheet VAu 486 472 Plio Model Sheet VAu 486 479 Suri Model Sheet VAu 486 471 Yar Model Sheet VA 996 530 Dinosaur - Phase I Style Guide VA 992 942 Dinosaur - Phase II Style Guide PA 940 885 The Emperor's New Groove Motion Picture VA 999 573 Emporer's New Groove Style Guide VAu 479 682 Kronk Model Sheet VAu 479 685 Kuzco Model Sheet VAu 479 683 Kuzco Llama Model Sheet VAu 479 684 Pacha Model Sheet VAu 479 681 Yzma Model Sheet PA 1-250-536 The Incredibles Motion Picture VA 1-242-351 The Incredibles Style Guide PA 1-322-908 Cars Motion Picture VA 1-326-323 Cars -- Style Guide Style Guide VA 1-403-647 Hannah Montana -- Branding Guide Style Guide PA 659-601 Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Motion Picture

PA 1-313-530 High School Musical Motion Picture VA 1-405-082 High School Musical -- Branding Guide Style Guide

PA 1-627-575 Hannah Montana the Movie Motion Picture PA 1-635-067 Up Motion Picture PA 1-641-991 G-Force Motion Picture PA 1-606-305 Wall-E Motion Picture VA 1-663-815 Wall-E -- Branding and Supplement

Style Guide RSM 2008 Style Guide PA 1-598-561 High School Musical 2 Motion Picture VA 1-651-813 High School Musical 2 -- Summer

2008 Style Guide Supplement Style Guide PA 1-613-593 High School Musical 3: Senior Year Motion Picture VA 1-655-713 Beverly Hills Chihuahua One Sheet PA 1-611-956 Beverly Hills Chihuahua Motion Picture Pau 2-921-728 Little Mermaid III: Ariel's Beginning Screenplay VA 515-038 Little Mermaid III: Ariel's Beginning Comic Book PA 1-623-231 Bedtime Stories Motion Picture PA 1-588-972 Underdog Motion Picture PA 1-595-126 Enchanted Motion Picture PA 1-332-118 Meet the Robinsons Motion Picture VA 1-358-218 Meet the Robinsons-Style Guide Style Guide PA 1-122-518 Cinderella II Dreams come true / Motion Picture produced by Walt Disney Television Animation ; directed by John Kafka PA 1-612-331 Cinderella III: A Twist in Time Motion Picture PA 1-611-943 Tinker Bell Motion Picture PA 1-617-950 Bolt Motion Picture VA 1-663-828 Bolt -- Fall/Winter Style Guide 2008 Style Guide PA 1-688-323 Toy Story 3 Motion Picture VA 1-800-737 Toy Story 3: GC Product Dev -- Style Guide -- Spring/Summer 2010 Style Guide

EXHIBIT B

DEI'S TRADEMARKS Trademark Registration Trademark Mark Drawing Code Trademark Registration No. Date Mickey Mouse Typed Drawing 3,115,395 7/11/2006 Mickey Mouse Standard Character Mark 3,767,849 3/30/2010 Mickey Mouse Typed Drawing 3,006,349 10/11/2005 Mickey Mouse Typed Drawing 0,315,056 7/17/1934 Mickey Mouse Standard Character Mark 3,750,188 2/16/2010 Mickey Mouse Typed Drawing 1,152,389 4/28/1981 Mickey Mouse Design Only 2,704,887 4/8/2003 Mickey Mouse Head Device Design Only 2,781,693 11/11/2003 Minnie Mouse Typed Drawing 3,102,338 6/06/2006 Minnie Mouse Design Only 2,700,619 3/25/2003 Minnie Mouse Standard Character Mark 3,767,850 3/30/2010 Minnie Mouse Standard Character Mark 3,740,338 1/19/2010 Minnie Mouse Typed Drawing 3,002,502 9/27/2005 Pluto Typed Drawing 1,152,383 4/28/1981 Pluto Design Only 2,707,323 4/15/2003 Goofy Typed Drawing 1,159,124 6/30/1981 Goofy Design Only 2,721,608 6/3/2003 Donald Duck Typed Drawing 1,161,868 7/21/1981 Donald Duck Design Only 2,700,620 3/25/2003 Donald Duck Typed Drawing 3,150,077 9/26/2006 Daisy Duck Design Only 2,704,890 4/8/2003 Disney Typed Drawing 1,162,727 7/28/1981 Disney Typed Drawing 3,490,082 8/19/2008 Disney Princess Standard Character Mark 3,459,442 7/1/2008 Walt Disney Typed Drawing 1,141,312 11/11/1980 Walt Disney Signature Standard Character Mark 3,584,878 3/3/2009 Winnie the Pooh Typed Drawing 3,024,287 12/6/2005 Pooh Design Only 2,704,888 4/8/2003 Pooh Typed Drawing 3,395,652 3/11/2008 Piglet Standard Character Mark 4,118,780 3/27/2012 Piglet Design Only 2,700,618 3/25/2003 Tigger Design Only 2,860,445 7/6/2004 Eeyore Design Only 3,591,616 3/17/2009 Eeyore Typed Drawing 3,464,628 7/8/2008 Eeyore Standard Character Mark 3,658,573 7/21/2009 Walt Disney's Cinderella Design Plus Words, Numbers 3,057,988 2/7/2006 Walt Disney's Snow White & the Seven Dwarfs Letters, and/or Design Plus Words, Letters, and/or Numbers 2,891,463 10/5/2004 Design Plus Words, Walt Disney's Sleeping Numbers 2,895,966 10/19/2004 Sleeping Beauty Standard Character Letters, and/or Beauty Mark 3,775,134 4/13/2010 Peter Pan Standard Character Mark 3,745,492 2/2/2010 Walt Disney's Peter Pan Design Plus Words, Numbers 2,895,967 10/19/2004 Peter Pan Standard Character Letters, and/or Mark 3,662,111 7/28/2009 Tinker Bell Standard Character Mark 3,648,929 7/20/2006 Tinker Bell Standard Character Mark 3,636,910 6/9/2009 Tinker Bell Design Only 3,624,833 5/19/2009 Tink Typed Drawing 3,734,512 1/5/2010 Hannah Montana Standard Character Mark 3,478,026 7/29/2008 Hannah Montana Standard Character Mark 3,413,555 4/15/2008 Hannah Montana Standard Character Mark 3,473,757 7/22/2008 Hannah Montana Standard Character Mark 3,413,552 4/15/2008 Lilo & Stitch Typed Drawing 2,811,097 2/3/2004 Lilo & Stitch Typed Drawing 2,845,107 5/25/2004 Pinocchio Standard Character Mark Serial Number 77618061 n/a Pinocchio Standard Character Mark Serial Number 77625073 n/a Cars Design Plus Words, Numbers 3,358,115 12/18/2007 Cars Design Plus Words, Letters, and/or Letters, and/or Numbers 3,178,664 11/28/2006 Lightning McQueen Standard Character Mark 3,370,157 1/15/2008 Mater Standard Character Mark 3,406,600 4/1/2008 Rust-Eze Standard Character Mark 3,294,617 9/18/2007 Doc Hudson Standard Character Mark 3,321,900 10/23/2007 Toy Story Typed Drawing 2,520,404 12/18/2001 Toy Story Standard Character Mark 3,971,114 5/31/2011 Ariel Standard Character Mark 3,814,910 7/6/2010 Beauty and the Beast Typed Drawing 2,961,693 6/14/2005 Princess Jasmine Standard Character Mark 3,998,366 7/19/2011 Princess Jasmine Standard Character Mark Serial Number 85,182,806 n/a High School Musical Standard Character Mark 3,506,572 9/23/2008 High School Musical Standard Character Mark 3,433,096 5/20/2008 High School Musical Standard Character Mark 3,420,394 10/24/2006 High School Musical Standard Character Mark 3,469,823 7/15/2008 Meet the Robinsons Standard Character Mark 3,420,082 4/29/2008 Meet the Robinsons Standard Character Mark 3,354,473 12/11/2007 The Cheetah Girls Standard Character Mark 3,252,269 6/12/2007 Walt Disney Pictures Presents The Wild Standard Character Mark 3,389,689 2/26/2008 Disney Bolt Standard Character Mark 3,648,251 6/30/2009 Disney Bolt Standard Character Mark 3,604,222 4/7/2009 Wall-E Standard Character Mark 3,686,824 9/22/2009 Wall-E Standard Character Mark 3,528,986 11/4/2008 Handy Manny Standard Character Mark 3,276,261 8/7/2007 Handy Manny Standard Character Mark 3,643,979 6/23/2009

EXHIBIT C

WARNER BROS.' COPYRIGHTED DESIGNS

Copyright Registration Title Of Work

(Character) Type of Work

TXU 550963 Bugs Bunny (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550472 Sylvester (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550958 Sylvester Jr. (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550444 Taz-Mania (1991) Style Guide

TXU 550812 Tweety (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550953 Wile E. Coyote (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550962 Yosemite Sam (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550471 Acme Road Gear (1992) Style Guide

TXU-550463 Daffy Duck (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550960 Elmer Fudd (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550470 Looney Tunes Guidelines (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550961 Marc Antony & Pussyfoot

(1992) Style Guide

TXU 550959 Marvin The Martian (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550957 Pepe Le Pew & Penelope (1992) Style Guide

TXU 551162 Porky Pig & Petunia Pig (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550955 Road Runner (1992) Style Guide

TXU 550964 Speedy Gonzales (1992) Style Guide

TXU 557335 Tasmanian Devil (1992) Style Guide

TXU 568671 The Warner Brothers (1992) Style Guide

EXHIBIT D

WARNER BROS. TRADEMARKS

Trademark Name Registration No Reg. Date

BUGS BUNNY 950381 9-Jan-1973

BUGS BUNNY 2046053 18-Mar-1997

DAFFY DUCK 1998415 3-Sept-1996

ELMER FUDD 1997173 27-Aug-1996

LOONEY TUNES 1574797 2-Jan-1990

PORKY PIG 2062712 20-May-1997

ROAD RUNNER 2000037 10-Sept-1996

TASMANIAN DEVIL 2033589 28-Jan-1997

TWEETY 1997174 27-Aug-1996

BUGS BUNNY 1235144 19-Apr-1983

BUGS BUNNY 2046053 18-Mar-1997

BUGS BUNNY 1065358 10-May-1977

BUGS BUNNY 0950381 09-Jan-1973

BUGS BUNNY 1872565 10-Jan-1995

BUGS BUNNY 1280858 05-Jun-1984

BUGS BUNNY 1869300 27-Dec-1994

BUGS BUNNY 2030106 14-Jan-1997

BUGS BUNNY 1280778 05-Jun-1984

Bugs Bunny Head Rep I 0966881 28-Aug-1973

Bugs Bunny Head Rep III 1291403 21-Aug-1984

Bugs Bunny Rep IX (Cool Bunny w/

Carrot) 1873919 17-Jan-1995

Bugs Bunny Rep IX (Cool Bunny w/

Carrot) 1872300 10-Jan-1995

Bugs Bunny Rep XII (Carrot, Jacket,

Bow Tie) 1293720 11-Sep-1984

Bugs Bunny Rep XIII (Mouth Open,

Hands on Hips) 2775393 21-Oct-2003

DAFFY DUCK 1869296 27-Dec-1994

DAFFY DUCK 1872619 10-Jan-1995

DAFFY DUCK 1290368 14-Aug-1984

DAFFY DUCK 1873922 17-Jan-1995

DAFFY DUCK 1998415 03-Sep-1996

Daffy Duck Head Rep 1286233 17-Jul-1984

Daffy Duck Rep V (Hands on Hips) 1879823 21-Feb-1995

Daffy Duck Rep VII (Leaning Right) 1916145 05-Sep-1995

Daffy Duck Rep VIII (Swinging

Left) 3005978 11-Oct-2005

Daffy Duck Rep XIV 1294387 11-Sep-1984

ELMER FUDD 1997173 27-Aug-1996

ELMER FUDD 2017978 19-Nov-1996

ELMER FUDD 1916032 05-Sep-1995

Elmer Fudd Rep a 1916170 05-Sep-1995

Elmer Fudd Rep V (Smiling,

Waving) 1873920 17-Jan-1995

FLIX FROM THE FROG 2975170 26-Jul-2005

FOGHORN LEGHORN 1914590 29-Aug-1995

Foghorn Leghorn Rep 1873923 17-Jan-1995

Foghorn Leghorn Rep II 1898748 13-Jun-1995

GOSSAMER 2199970 27-Oct-1998

LOLA BUNNY 2530472 15-Jan-2002

LOONEY TUNES 1574797 02-Jan-1990

LOONEY TUNES 1297890 25-Sep-1984

LOONEY TUNES 1300078 16-Oct-1984

LOONEY TUNES & Target w/ Bugs

Bunny Logo (WB in Shield) 2257588 29-Jun-1999

LOONEY TUNES BACK IN

ACTION 2949693 10-May-2005

LOONEY TUNES BACK IN

ACTION 2839227 04-May-2004

Looney Tunes Theme Song (sound mark) 2469364 17-Jul-2001

Looney Tunes Theme Song (sound mark) 2471345 24-Jul-2001

MARVIN THE MARTIAN 1872563 10-Jan-1995

MARVIN THE MARTIAN 2502729 30-Oct-2001

Marvin the Martian Head Rep II 1888336 ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.