ECF No.
|
Document(s) to be Sealed
|
Ruling
|
Reasoning
|
337-4
|
Bloch Decl. Exh. Y
|
GRANTED as to entire document.
|
Agreement between a current StarStar Mobile
customer and Zoove Corp. Shows specific prices for
a current customer through 2020. Public disclosure
of this information would harm VHT StarStar. Hayden
Decl. ¶ 2, ECF 337-1.
|
337-6
|
Bloch Decl. Exh. Z
|
GRANTED as to highlighted portions.
|
Document discloses VHT StarStar's commercial
contracts with customers other than Sumotext,
including sensitive personal information and
proprietary business information. No sealing is
sought as to Sumotext's contracts with its
customers. Hayden Decl. ¶ 3, ECF 337-1.
|
337-8
|
Bloch Decl. Exh. AA
|
GRANTED as to highlighted portions.
|
Internal VHT StarStar email forwarding a pricing
communication with a current** customer. VHT
StarStar considers this document
confidential and would be harmed if competitors in
the market for mobile engagement were able to see
its pricing negotiations with this customer. Hayden
Decl. ¶ 4, ECF 337-1.
|
337-10
|
Bloch Decl. Exh. FF
|
GRANTED as to highlighted portions.
|
VHT StarStar's commercial contracts with
customers other than Sumotext, and summaries of
same, contain sensitive personal information and
proprietary business information. Hayden Decl.
¶ 5, ECF 337-1.
|
337-12
|
Bloch Decl. Exh. GG
|
GRANTED as to highlighted portions.
|
StarStar Mobile's referral agreements with 17
referral agents, are treated as confidential and
disclosure could harm StarStar Mobile's
business. Hayden Decl. ¶ 6, ECF 337-1.
|
337-14
|
Bloch Decl. Exh. OO
|
GRANTED as to highlighted portions.
|
Contains confidential information regarding a
contract between StarStar Mobile and a current
customer. StarStar Mobile treats is customer
contracts as confidential and would be harmed if
competitors could see its contracts. Hayden Decl.
¶ 7, ECF 337-1.
|
337-16
|
Bloch Decl. Exh. PP
|
GRANTED as to highlighted portions.
|
Contains historical information about major
customers that Defendants treat as confidential and
competitively sensitive. Hayden Decl. ¶ 8, ECF
337-1.
|
355-4
|
Plaintiff's opposition to Defendants'
motion for summary judgment
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants in
ECF 356-48.
|
Memorandum quotes from confidential materials as to
which the Court grants sealing.
|
355-6
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 7
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants in
ECF 356-4.
|
Discloses StarStar Mobile's future business
plans. Hayden Decl. ¶ 2, ECF 356-1.
|
355-7
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 10
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants in
ECF 356-6.
|
Discloses StarStar Mobile's future business
plans. Hayden Decl. ¶ 3, ECF 356-1.
|
355-13
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 13
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-8.
|
Discloses specific discounts and proprietary
pricing information. Levitt Decl. ¶ 2, ECF
342-1.
|
355-8
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 15
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-10.
|
Discloses identify of potential customer. Hayden
Decl. ¶ 4, ECF 356-1.
|
355-8
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 16
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-12.
|
Discloses specifics of contractual arrangements
with mobile carriers. Hayden Decl. ¶ 5, ECF
356-1.
|
355-8
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 17
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-14.
|
Discloses specifics of pricing and contractual
arrangements with potential ** customer. Hayden
Decl. ¶ 6, ECF 356-1.
|
355-9
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 20
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-16.
|
Exhibit 20 is a compilation of unrelated emails.
The defendants seek to seal only those portions
revealing confidential business discussions,
including prices and bank routing and account
information. Doumar Dec. ¶ 13, ECF 356-2.
|
355-9
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 21
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-18
|
Summary of events prepared by StarSteve in
connection with fundraising for the acquisition of
Zoove that includes valuation and investor
information that is confidential could harm
StarSteve if made public. Doumar Decl. ¶ 3,
ECF 356-2.
|
355-9
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 22
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-20.
|
E-mail that included a draft of the Letter of
Intent and that explains confidential internal
negotiations regarding the structure of VHT
StarStar, LLC and the possible financial
arrangements among its owners. Doumar Decl. ¶
4, ECF 356-2.
|
355-9
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 23
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-22.
|
E-mail sent to investors for StarSteve that
contains (a) a summary of business methods that
reflects strategic direction and key insights into
business approaches, as well as financial
summaries, all of which would be harmful if it were
provided to competitors, as well as (b) a draft
letter of intent with financial information
regarding the VHT StarStar, LLC entity and the
valuation of the business, which is also highly
confidential and would be harmful if made public.
Doumar Decl. ¶ 5, ECF 356-2.
|
355-10
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 26
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-24.
|
Contains information as to what ** numbers StarStar
Mobile continues to be most valuable, which impacts
pricing information. StarStar Mobile treats such
internal information as highly confidential. Hayden
Decl. ¶ 7, ECF 356-1.
|
355-10
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 27
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-26.
|
E-mail discussing the carrier relationships with
Zoove for VHT StarStar's business going
forward, treated as confidential. Doumar Decl.
¶ 6, ECF 356-2.
|
355-10
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 28
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-28.
|
Duplicate of Exh. 10 and sealable for same reasons.
Hayden Decl. ¶ 3, ECF 356-1.
|
355-11
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 32
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-30.
|
E-mail sent to a potential investor in StarSteve,
that contains (a) a summary of business methods
that reflects strategic direction and key insights
into business approaches, as well as financial
summaries, all of which would be harmful if it were
provided to competitors, (b) the summary of events
discussed above, and (c) a draft letter of intent
with financial information regarding the VHT
StarStar, LLC entity and the valuation of the
business, which is also highly confidential and
would be harmful if made public. Doumar Decl.
¶ 7, ECF 356-2.
|
355-11
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh.33
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-32.
|
Communications regarding a potential investment
(which did not occur) including (a) private
financial account information and (b) details about
StarSteve and its business activities and its
financial structure which is confidential and would
be potentially damaging to the Company's future
efforts to raise money if publicly known. Doumar
Decl. ¶ 8, ECF 356-2.
|
ECF 355-12
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 35
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-34.
|
Financial due diligence report on Zoove, prepared
by Mblox and furnished to VHT StarStar in November
2015. It contains highly detailed financial
information concerning Zoove that would be damaging
if known, even two or three years after the fact.
Hayden Decl. ¶ 8, ECF 356-1.
|
ECF 355-13
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 39
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-36.
|
Discloses StarStar Mobile's financial
performance over time, customer and reseller
business arrangements, particular business
prospects, and problems with StarStar Mobile's
vendors. Leavitt Decl. ¶ 3, ECF 342-1.
|
355-14
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 41
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-38.
|
E-mail regarding pricing for **HYATT, which
information is confidential competitive information
and commercially sensitive. Doumar Decl. ¶ 9,
ECF 356-2.
|
355-15
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 43
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
356-40.
|
Email exchange disclosing pricing and contractual
arrangements for a particular ** customer seeking
to least particular ** numbers. Pricing discussions
are treated as confidential by StarStar Mobile and
would be harmful if revealed. Hayden Decl. ¶
9, ECF 356-1.
|
355-16
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh.47
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-42.
|
Operating Agreement for VHT StarStar, LLC
containing confidential information about the
Company's ownership and financial structure.
Doumar Decl. ¶ 10, ECF 356-2.
|
355-16
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 48
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-44.
|
Stock Purchase Agreement by which VHT StarStar
acquired Zoove from Mblox. The Agreement specifies
it is to remain confidential and it has been held
in confidence. Hayden Decl. ¶ 10, ECF 356-1.
|
355-16
|
Greathouse Decl. Exh. 51
|
GRANTED as to portions highlighted by Defendants at
ECF 356-46
|
Excerpts of Doumar deposition discussing ownership
structure of StarSteve and identity of investors,
all of which is and has been treated as
confidential. Doumar Decl. ¶ 11, ECF 356-2.
|